Conservative Party Election Manifesto GE2024
Headlines for CLA
On 11 June the Conservative Party published its manifesto: ‘Clear Plan, Bold Action, Secure Future’. The Party has centred much of its manifesto overall on its commitments to grow the economy, provide young people with opportunities to develop skills and to support the labour market, and address issues surrounding migration and health.
Education forms a central part of the manifesto, with commitments on improving parental support and childcare, strengthening the standard of primary and secondary education, and improving opportunities in further education and skills training. The Party has formed these commitments around an aspiration where ‘young people always get the skills they need to succeed.’ They aim to 100,000 new apprenticeships in England every year by the end of the next Parliament – paid for by curbing the number of poor-quality university degrees. Two points to note included:
On schools:
- Support children in their transition to secondary school and ensure they continue to receive a broad and ‘enriched’ education during and after school, including via the multi-million-pound Music Hubs.
On further education and skills:
- Work with the creative industries to deliver a dedicated flexible coordination service so that everyone who wants to work in the film, TV, gaming and music sectors can work on live productions whilst benefiting from at least 12 months of secure training.
OUr Take
It’s important to say that not a whole lot was said about arts and creative subjects in comparison with other manifestos. The strategic prioritisation of non-arts subjects was maintained through the announcement of tax-free bonuses of £30,000 for teachers in STEM and ‘technical’ subjects (also extended to teachers in FE colleges). As we have observed in past newsletters, every young person being made to study maths to age 18 may not go down well with students who particularly lean towards arts and humanities subjects. Maths and sport get plenty of coverage, but the arts only get a specific mention in relation to music, long held to be the highest art form by the Conservative party, with a pledge to ensure children continue to receive a ‘broad and enriched’ education during and after school, including via the ‘multi-million-pound Music Hubs.’ (Look out for an article on the far from simple situation with Music Hubs in our July newsletter).
The Conservatives will maintain parental choice by preserving the rights of independent schools and grammar schools and refrain from taxing independent special schools. See our 2024 Report Card for details of the clear and divisive ‘enrichment gap’ in our education system.
There is also a continuation of the narrative about ‘rip off’ degrees which we would counter by reiterating the statement we recently gave to Arts Professional on this subject: ‘It is not helpful for government policy to prioritise learning to count over learning to create, nor the amount a new graduate earns over their contribution to society. When a government determines that Expressive Arts subjects are strategically unimportant the arts become systematically eroded in schools and in the higher education sector, even when we know that as well as being valuable for young people’s wellbeing, the capacities, confidence, creativity and skills gained through arts subjects are being increasingly prioritised by employers. This is wider than just degree qualifications: a system with the objective of creating the employees of the future is failing to embrace what employers say they want from young people entering the workforce. The new government’s investment areas and industrial strategy need to align with a new and ambitious national education and skills strategy, with arts and creative subjects embedded as valued and equal subjects areas in schools, and across the university sector.’
We also note that there is no mention of the Cultural Education Plan announced in 2022 and which has still not been published.
GREEN Party Election Manifesto GE2024
Headlines for CLA
On 12 June the Green Party launched its manifesto – ‘Real Hope. Real Change’. The manifesto centres around security and sustainable development, addressing the climate emergency and creating a ‘greener, fairer’ future for Britain. As part of the Green Party’s mission to make ambitious commitments to create a fairer and greener world, proposed education policies include:
- Move academy trusts and free schools to local authority control.
- Abolish the two-child benefit cap, lifting 250,000 children out of poverty.
- Provide all children with a free school meal each day and provide free breakfast clubs for children to Year 6.
- Support every higher education student, with the restoration of grants, the end of tuition fees and the cancellation of graduate debt, as well as restoration of the Education Maintenance Allowance to financially support young people to extend their studies after the age of 16.
On the arts, there were only two main points of relevance including:
- Review assessment targets in schools to treat arts and vocational subjects equally within the curriculum, as well as supporting children to play and learn outdoors and teach all children about the climate and biodiversity.
- Introduce a £5bn investment to support community sports, arts and culture to support grassroots sports clubs and fund keeping local museums, theatres, libraries and art galleries open and thriving.
OUr Take
We welcome the review of assessment targets in line with our own manifesto asks, the support for arts and culture through communities, and the focus on children’s mental health. We also welcome the re-establishment of the Education Maintenance Allowance for FE students in England, which was scrapped by the Coalition Government in 2010. However, the manifesto stops short of creating an entitlement for Expressive Arts education in schools.
Labour Election Manifesto GE2024
On 13 June the Labour Party published its manifesto – ‘Change’ – which outlines Labour’s ‘First Steps for Change’ to improve Britain. Labour has positioned itself as the Party to deliver significant reform following the Conservative Party’s time in government, with change being a core message throughout the manifesto.
The Party has provided a lot of detail on its education pledges, and has centred many of its education priorities around its mission to break down barriers to ensure all young people get the opportunities they deserve. Securing economic stability for Britain is a thread running throughout the manifesto, with Labour identifying high-quality education and skills training as being central to achieving this. Labour aims to get more teachers into shortage subjects, support areas that face recruitment challenges and tackle retention issues, and introduce a new teacher training entitlement.
Headlines for CLA
They will launch an expert-led review of curriculum and assessment, working with school staff, parents and employers, and want to build on the work of teachers who have brought their subjects alive with knowledge-rich syllabuses to deliver a curriculum which is rich and broad, inclusive and innovative. ‘Every child should have a broad curriculum with an excellent foundation in reading, writing and maths, and support to develop essential digital, speaking and creative skills’. They state that the review will consider the right balance of assessment methods.
On the creative arts, it highlights:
- Supporting children to study a creative or vocational subject until they are 16, and ensuring accountability measures reflect this.
- Implementing a creative industries sector action plan as part of the party’s Industrial Strategy, creating jobs and accelerating growth in film, music, gaming and other creative sectors.
- Launching a new National Music Education Network – a one-stop shop with information on courses and classes for parents, teachers and children.
OUR TAKE
We welcome the review of curriculum and assessment (and the curriculum intention wording – ‘broad, inclusive and innovative’) and hope that the review will be deep and far-reaching, also addressing the purposes of schooling, and mapping curriculum areas onto purposes. With regard to reviewing assessment, we hope that scrapping the EBacc altogether is not off the table.
While we welcome interest in music education, we hope that policy attention and investment are directed towards all Expressive Arts subjects and not just music. We value the mission to break down barriers to opportunity for young people, and we support the link between education and industry with the identification of high-quality education and skills training being central to achieving economic stability. We also value the commitment to a creative industries sector action plan and the intention to replace a single Ofsted headline grade with a new report card system.
It is also important to note that one of the main headings under the ‘Break down barriers to opportunity’ section in the manifesto is entitled ‘Access to arts, music and sport’ – a small detail, but nevertheless important in reflecting a commitment to the arts and recognition of their importance in education.
Liberal Democrat Election Manifesto GE2024
On 10 June the Liberal Democrats published their manifesto, ‘For a Fair Deal’. Education is a key aspect of the manifesto, described as the ‘best investment’ in the potential of children and the country’s future. The Liberal Democrats want every child to get the support and attention they need at school so that they leave with the skills, confidence and resilience to be happy and successful.
Headlines for CLA
Changes to the state of arts education in schools is mentioned in three points:
- Establish a standing commission to broaden curricula by drawing on best practice and ensuring children learn core skills including critical thinking, verbal reasoning and creativity.
- Include arts subjects in the English Baccalaureate and give power to Ofsted to monitor the curriculum so that schools continue to provide a rich curriculum including subjects like art, music or drama.
- Introducing a free entitlement for disadvantaged children to access extracurricular activities such as art, music or drama.
- Creating a teacher workforce strategy which ensures students are taught by a specialist teacher in their subject area.
OUR TAKE
We very much welcome the recognition of the value of Expressive Arts subjects in the Lib Dem manifesto, although we don’t think that including arts subjects in the EBacc is going far enough, and our manifesto asks call for the EBacc to be scrapped altogether. We value recognition that students should be taught by trained specialists and that the plans for a teacher workforce strategy aim to address this. We also value the focus on disadvantaged and SEND children in the manifesto, as well as on child mental health, and the desire to scrap one-word Ofsted judgements.